Re: [OTDE]: Give me a track and I'll classify it!

by rabid squirrel Sun Mar 27, 2016 2:25 pm

Are you sure silhouette is classicist? I would probably disagree with you there. I'd say it's more formalist.

by ScrungleBlumpkus Sun Mar 27, 2016 5:07 pm

Doesn't it kinda depend on intention?

by **OTDE** Sun Mar 27, 2016 5:12 pm

Not always! Sheldon typically makes things with the intention of doing something relatively classicist (i.e. be the BEST at THIS THING) and will sometimes accidentally make something formalist (Retrograde, WTK)

Also, for its time, Silhouette was definitely formalist.

by **Conundrumer** Sun Mar 27, 2016 9:08 pm

OTDE wrote:
Conundrumer wrote:ragdoll

Iconoclast as heck, dude.

objection

ragdoll was a manual track. I went through all possible crawl positions (I could have done a better job making this clear but I only had 48 hours), and the brief mid/hi speed crawl section with the loops and flings was basically tail manuals.

music sync + dancing -> iconoclast
offsled experimentation + restriction to offsled manuals -> formalist

It's possible to be experimental and accessible at the same time. I'm trying to figure out how to do this for other mediums, in addition to Line Rider.

by **OTDE** Sun Mar 27, 2016 9:13 pm

Conundrumer wrote:
OTDE wrote:
Conundrumer wrote:ragdoll

Iconoclast as heck, dude.

objection

ragdoll was a manual track. I went through all possible crawl positions (I could have done a better job making this clear but I only had 48 hours), and the brief mid/hi speed crawl section with the loops and flings was basically tail manuals.

music sync + dancing -> iconoclast
offsled experimentation + restriction to offsled manuals -> formalist

It's possible to be experimental and accessible at the same time. I'm trying to figure out how to do this for other mediums, in addition to Line Rider.

experimental and accessible is literally textbook iconoclast
the fact that the track was accessible while experimenting is what makes it iconoclast. if it wasn't experimental and still accessible, it would be animist. if it's experimental without being accessible, it's formalist, and if it's neither, it's classicist

by **Conundrumer** Sun Mar 27, 2016 10:16 pm

OTDE wrote:
Conundrumer wrote:
OTDE wrote:
Conundrumer wrote:ragdoll

Iconoclast as heck, dude.

objection

ragdoll was a manual track. I went through all possible crawl positions (I could have done a better job making this clear but I only had 48 hours), and the brief mid/hi speed crawl section with the loops and flings was basically tail manuals.

music sync + dancing -> iconoclast
offsled experimentation + restriction to offsled manuals -> formalist

It's possible to be experimental and accessible at the same time. I'm trying to figure out how to do this for other mediums, in addition to Line Rider.

experimental and accessible is literally textbook iconoclast
the fact that the track was accessible while experimenting is what makes it iconoclast. if it wasn't experimental and still accessible, it would be animist. if it's experimental without being accessible, it's formalist, and if it's neither, it's classicist

I was taking a shower and then I had shower thoughts and came to your conclusion. I agree.

by gavinroo538 Sat Oct 13, 2018 9:58 pm

Does/Can this still exist?

Trees: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqM7L9YYArc
Taxi Cab: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oVmbUQvuMkI
build me up buttercup: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a3duRIgq2kc
GAS GAS GAS!!! (Probably the hardest one of mine to classify): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WY4jfPWPwzY

by rabid squirrel Thu Oct 18, 2018 2:22 am

heck, why not lol, here's my take

Trees: HELLA animist
Taxi Cab: also pretty animist but less traditionalist
build me up buttercup: hard one, I'm gonna say uhhhhhh weak animist/iconoclast mix
Gas Gas Gas: this one's easy, hard classicist

by gavinroo538 Thu Oct 18, 2018 4:13 pm

rabid squirrel wrote:heck, why not lol, here's my take

Trees: HELLA animist
Taxi Cab: also pretty animist but less traditionalist
build me up buttercup: hard one, I'm gonna say uhhhhhh weak animist/iconoclast mix
Gas Gas Gas: this one's easy, hard classicist

Whoa I guess this is alive! Well, kinda. Here's a challenge: Classify all of my published tracks! And I mean ALL of them! LET'S GO!!!
(Note: I'm also adding the ENHANCED version of Coloris and Gas Gas Gas just because of those appearing lines and stuff)

My Tracks:

ABC=Already Been Classified

by gavinroo538 Fri Oct 19, 2018 1:29 pm

gavinroo538 wrote:
rabid squirrel wrote:heck, why not lol, here's my take

Trees: HELLA animist
Taxi Cab: also pretty animist but less traditionalist
build me up buttercup: hard one, I'm gonna say uhhhhhh weak animist/iconoclast mix
Gas Gas Gas: this one's easy, hard classicist
Whoa I guess this is alive! Well, kinda. Here's a challenge: Classify all of my published tracks! And I mean ALL of them! LET'S GO!!!
(Note: I'm also adding the ENHANCED version of Coloris and Gas Gas Gas just because of those appearing lines and stuff)

My Tracks:

ABC=Already Been Classified

Dunno why, but I feel like classifying my own tracks.

If you wanna classify all of my tracks, then don't read this until you do:

by Sponsored content