Manuquirk Battle Voting!

Please re-watch every video before voting to provide a fair judgement. Vote for your favorite!

Unusuals - by Chuggers




Blue Confusion - by Theacp127




Preacher - by Ryderofthelines

Oh god Preacher is up against Unusuals??
Wow. So I'll try narrowing this down:

I love Blue Confusion, but it really doesn't quite stack up against the other two. Sorry, acp! I know you'll get to where they are soon!!

A lot of it boils down to the completeness of the track. Unusuals toys with a lot of cool things, but ultimately, preacher feels more complete, as well as more deliberate with its syncs. Each one is in lockstep with the music, and that's a huge part of what makes a track enjoyable for me.

Fun tracks all around, but Preacher ultimately gets my vote! Good job to all for doing some really awesome things in all of these tracks!

I've rewatched Unusuals and Preacher two times more and I have to go with Unusuals (Blue Confusion is a fun track, but doesn't quite stack up against the other two).

I might be missing music syncs in Preacher (looking at OTDE's post), but for me the syncing in Unusuals is actually better done. The music might lend itself better for it with the steady beat. This in combination with the quick speed changes from the quirk that pop Bosh in any direction on the beat just makes for a wonderful experience.

Other than that, I just really really love that head ride/second peg smooth loop in Unusuals that is timed at a moment where the music slowly sort of fades and bosh smoothly wooshes through this loop. It's such a pleasure to watch. Along with all the pops and jumbles and lots of other stuff that I won't specifially name. Basically I will keep coming back to rewatch Unusuals. Although Preacher is awesome, I won't come back and rewatch it. And this is not a bad thing, I don't rewatch a lot of tracks to begin with. Unusuals is just that fun for me to watch.

Probably it's just a personal preference, because I kind of agree with OTDE that Preacher feels more finished somehow. That colour replay of Unusuals though... So cool

Z_N-Freak wrote:Snips

To clarify what I meant, there were lots of little moments in Preacher where there were mini syncs-- manuals would switch at a stick-click in the song, or at a series of base hits. Unusuals is super cool and has a lot of sync elements, but they kind of fall to the wayside as the track progresses.

That's totally how it came off to me, though! There are tons of reasons to vote for either, and I know I had a tough time voting myself!

Staff, if the feature rule applies to battle polls, I won't post anymore, but I can't resist discussion about sync, it's one of the most important factors for me in the enjoyability of the tracks I watch

Blue confusion is really fun, but it got in the wrong place lol
I went with unusuals, because of the cool beats and those super stacked wells. This poll is difficult :o

OTDE wrote:Staff, if the feature rule applies to battle polls, I won't post anymore, but I can't resist discussion about sync, it's one of the most important factors for me in the enjoyability of the tracks I watch

Hah, I hope we won't have to make rules for battle polls!

(I voted preacher)

Bumpity. Vote people! There were more votes on the poll asking how you use toilet paper!

rabid squirrel wrote:

OTDE wrote:Staff, if the feature rule applies to battle polls, I won't post anymore, but I can't resist discussion about sync, it's one of the most important factors for me in the enjoyability of the tracks I watch

Hah, I hope we won't have to make rules for battle polls!

(I voted preacher)

I haven't been keeping up on the feature rules thread, but if the grace period between release and nomination passes, it should also go for release of polls. Hype for a track can die down pretty quick

you can agree on it at the start if the battle but I'm not going to make it a rule for all battles

Thanks for the few votes I got guys haha. I went with the unusuals since I really enjoyed it.

whoops, we never gave out a winged PIP for this. Hah! especially funny because chugs makes the PIPs.

EDIT: done now